The four ways

Barbour's typology of how science and religion can relate to each other.

Barbour set out four broad ways in which people have related science and religion. He presented it in his Gifford Lectures, published as Religion in an Age of Science (1990). Details still to be checked against the book.

Conflict

Science and religion make rival claims about the same things, so one of them must be wrong. Barbour gave scientific materialism and biblical literalism as the two sides.

Independence

Science and religion ask different questions in different languages, so they cannot conflict. Each keeps to its own territory.

Dialogue

The two meet at the edges: questions science raises but cannot answer, and similarities in how each builds and tests its ideas.

Integration

Scientific and religious ideas are brought together into one picture. Barbour’s own sympathies lay here, especially with process philosophy.